Today in class we discussed Walter Benjamin's essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction." Benjamin writes of the new place of art post development of film. In wake of mass communication technology, much of the cult aura surrounding masterworks is shattered. Benjamin postulates that in this new world art would assume a central role, crucial to the very heart of politics.
What I found particularly fascinating was the impact of time and place in understanding Benjamin's writing. When I first began reading the article I had been under impression that the piece was first written in 1968. Thus when presented with talk of Marx (and especially Fascism at a later point) I began wondering how relevant the essay could have been even in its day. However I soon realized I had made a vital error in approaching Benjamin, and had to adjust to understand the time that had produced it.
The next hurdle to understanding came with knowing something about Benjamin himself. Walter Benjamin was a German literary critic. More specifically, he was a Marxist and a Jewish mysticist during a period of history when either could mean death in Nazi Germany. He would have thus had a naturally critical eye for Nazi activity during the 1930s. So we see the impact of place too on the author's writing.
As Benjamin came to realize, Fascism was a political movement that had fallen in love with technology. Hitler often rode in a Mercedes-Benz, the armies of Fascist nations paraded the most state-of-the-art weaponry, and Riefenstahl's Triumph of the Will was the pinnacle of what mechanical reproduction could accomplish. It is from this last one that Benjamin undoubtedly came to understand the Fascist desire to aestheticize politics for the purpose of control. His arguments on mechanical reproduction are entirely shaped by his particular experiences. How do you think Barthes would respond to this assumption? What about Foucault?
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
Thursday, September 13, 2007
Authors in Popular Media (Assignment 1)
For the first project of semester we will each choose a film that deals with authorship. The paper should explain the general storyline of the film and describe the way in which the author is portrayed. The goal, of course, is to compare this representation with the philosophical and academic probing of authorship which we have been exploring in class. Having looked at Barthes, Foucault, and Benjamin we should have ample material to draw on.
After considering several options I am now more or less set on using the 2005 film "Capote." The movie follows a popular writer from the "New Yorker" to Kansas and the scene of grisly murders. Capote becomes deeply involved in the small town of Holcomb and, through extensive interviews, begins to feel a sort of compassion for the prisoners. He faces several unique situations, including a conflict between his own feelings and the desire for the proper ending to his book--an execution. The unusual position of feeling for his subjects as he does and being actively involved in their unfolding stories, a sort of new character himself, is a strange blurring of the author-subject relationship. In short I believe "Capote" will prove both entertaining in preparation for the paper as well as the source of excellent material. Any thoughts?
After considering several options I am now more or less set on using the 2005 film "Capote." The movie follows a popular writer from the "New Yorker" to Kansas and the scene of grisly murders. Capote becomes deeply involved in the small town of Holcomb and, through extensive interviews, begins to feel a sort of compassion for the prisoners. He faces several unique situations, including a conflict between his own feelings and the desire for the proper ending to his book--an execution. The unusual position of feeling for his subjects as he does and being actively involved in their unfolding stories, a sort of new character himself, is a strange blurring of the author-subject relationship. In short I believe "Capote" will prove both entertaining in preparation for the paper as well as the source of excellent material. Any thoughts?
Friday, September 7, 2007
We're up and running...
So it seems we've got a Blog on our hands.
The purpose of this particular Blog is to gather and share information with my classmates throughout the Fall '07 semester. I'll be posting at least once a week, often responding to another user's comments or expanding on something discussed during class time. In addition to course material I'll try to bring in other outside examples to keep things fresh. I'll also experiment with links to other things. Any suggestions are appreciated. Enjoy!
Note:
The course website is...
https://mywebspace.wisc.edu/rsbarnett/web/eng201_authorship/index.html
The purpose of this particular Blog is to gather and share information with my classmates throughout the Fall '07 semester. I'll be posting at least once a week, often responding to another user's comments or expanding on something discussed during class time. In addition to course material I'll try to bring in other outside examples to keep things fresh. I'll also experiment with links to other things. Any suggestions are appreciated. Enjoy!
Note:
The course website is...
https://mywebspace.wisc.edu/rsbarnett/web/eng201_authorship/index.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)