Thursday, November 8, 2007

Further Thoughts on Sampling

As I wrote in my Reflection (below), I enjoyed Sampling the most of all the projects thus far. I think Plagiarism, even as an assignment, was still too morally murky for me to really have fun with. Ghostwriting was entertaining because of the creative challenge inherent to it, but I was also frustrated trying to match a style of poetry that was less developed, maybe, than what I'm used to reading. Sampling, however, left me with a genuine feeling of authorship. Even the Sampling derived largely of copyrighted images felt like a new creation that I had made. I think the process of Sampling is a creative one, and that taking those elements and assembling them into something new is as valid a form of authorship as any.
That said, I'm curious how everyone went about their Sampling. I tried using the Creative Commons Search Engine (http://search.creativecommons.org/), however I had trouble getting anything of substance with it. Maybe I was looking for the wrong things, but I didn't find it especially helpful. I know Joe said the Directory is a more effective way to go about a search. In the end I basically gave up and just used a bunch of things I drew by hand.
I'm also curious how everyone planned their arguments. I basically brainstormed some thoughts on authorship (no author is entirely free of influence, the author is not limited to the written word, there is a legal battle frequently pitting large established groups against individuals over the future of what can be used, etc.). From there I chose recognizable images that could convey those thoughts, which proved fairly easy. In my Sampling every piece is intentionally placed (for example, the moon and snow are part of the second Sampling for a reason despite looking like filler). I tried to make the overall appearance part of my argument as well, taking space and positions into account. It might take some thought but I believe there are reasons for everything. How did you all do your Sampling?

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

A Reflection on Sampling

Sampling involves taking an array of images and words, typically from popular culture, and recombining them in a novel fashion so as to create an argument. Although I was familiar with the idea of Sampling in the abstract, I didn't realize Sampling was considered an important part of creativity, particularly one threatened by extensive copyright restrictions.
While I'm still uncertain what Sampling sounds like in the context of music, I learned that Sampling can be quite effective in making a statement or an argument. Sampling is typically an appeal to the eye, and is therefore made as aesthetically pleasing as possible (something I struggled with as I worked on my Sampling). Sampling can be done relatively quickly, and can carry considerable weight. As I reflected I thought it similar to the old saying: "a picture is worth a thousand words." When an author makes his appeal in the form of Sampling, he engages his audience (I'm not sure the appropriate term) by asking them to read into the work. He encourages them to search, to interpret, to engage the medium in a way that is different from an essay or article.
As I underwent the transformation into Sampler, I quickly realized free access to many resources trumps free access to limited resources. For a Sampling to be effective (in my humble opinion), the Sampler has to connect with his audience on a certain level. The ability to take well-known images from the popular culture can create a more meaningful argument by sheer virtue of recognition. The Sampler's work is understood at a variety of levels because of the cultural subconscious. While an argument made with permissible material can be very effective, it is certainly more difficult for the Sampler to articulate his argument while tip-toeing around legal repercussions. I believe we as a society have universally recognized symbols, many of which are under the ownership of a select few. A Sampling may find ways around the control of these powers and retain the spirit of the argument, but it may lose the power of its message by restraints placed on instantly recognizable images.
Regarding my work, I felt the argument that ripped and reused without concern for legality created a more effective statement. The possibilities were easily more plentiful and I felt I could make the Sampling richer through certain well-known images. I am unfortunately new to Photoshop and similar software, and with time constraints, I ended up making my Sampling by hand. As I thought about that I realized just how much more digital Sampling can do. In that way I felt increasing respect for Samplers. To me they are just as much an author as the individuals who created the elements incorporated in the Sampling. There is a definite creativity, a very clear innovation and alteration, which makes Sampling unique. I think Sampling is the most accurate picture of creation and authorship we have. As has long been known, there is almost nothing written completely uniquely. No author is an island; he is influenced and draws on the work of humanity's greats. It is his manipulation, his tweaking and shifting, his imagination, his new angle, that truly represents authorship.

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Free Culture Reflection

Lawrence Lessig's book "Free Culture" was a considerable divergence from my normal reading habits. I came into the book with next to no knowledge about copyright or the war on free culture. By the time I left, I'd like to think I know a little bit more.


The idea behind "Free Culture" didn’t hold me at first. I believed, erroneously, that the only thing at stake was the online world of piracy. To be honest, I didn’t particularly care if people were no longer able to steal music, movies, books, etc. online. I would have said, “okay, make it impossible and put it back to the way things were. I don’t care.” Lessig woke me from the happy misconception that only the bad guys were at their end and showed me a world teetering on the illogical and bizarre.

I think Lessig presented a powerful case. His examples are numerous and frequently infuriating. In case after case people are crushed by insensitive corporations for the sole purpose of profit. What makes the danger more severe is the threat to the creative future and potential hindrances to advancing our society, both through our culture and technology. I’m not all that naïve about government, but I was nonetheless shocked to hear how the law had been manipulated by the few.

As was suggested in class, I think this is a powerful read because of the passion Lessig brings to the narrative. He is clearly wounded from the Eldred decision, and this as his chance to make things right is not wasted.

For my part I will be sure to listen more closely when news of the legal status of creativity comes up. As a person maybe that’s all you can really do—be aware, I mean, so that when the cue comes up in conversation you can share the truth as best any of us can know it (unless you’re on a date, in which case I would think your company most likely to be disinterested in the nuances of publishing and ownership). In any case I’m grateful for having had the chance to read the book.

PS

My first reaction was to boycott Disney and the other groups operating like gangsters. The problem is that doesn’t really work, because I couldn’t care less about them right now. However once one has children, I imagine it is the “bad” parent who prohibits them from partaking in the 5-year-olds only real culture. Is there any alternative to this, sort of writing and illustrating one’s own line of bedtime stories?

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Free Culture II

In Lawrence Lessig's chapter on Piracy he says the courts rejected Napster technology capable of blocking 99.4% of copyright infringing material. From this he concludes that we are witnessing "a war on file-sharing technologies, not a war on copyright infringement. There is no way to assure that a p2p system is used 100 percent of the time in compliance with the law, any more than there is a way to assure that 100 percent of VCRs or 100 percent of Xerox machines or 100 percent of handguns are used in compliance with the law."
As I was considering this my thoughts reflected something Lessig had written earlier in the same chapter: "...the vast majority of it (type C sharing) is unavailable solely because the publisher or the distributor has decided it no longer makes economic sense to the company to make it available." P2P systems are exactly what do not make sense to the company. They are a potentially world-wide distribution system operated under the direction of an individual. Their existence began as outside the control of the corporate powers, and they offered the potential to do away with or substantially downsize an established system. Any competition, no matter how slight, is crushed according to sound business practice. The corporate giants are obviously looking to do just that to squash or control their competition. Despite many benefits of p2p, the record companies and others cannot allow it to flourish because it does not make sense to them. The way things currently are mean the p2p-users are helpless against the company will. The established powers have the capital and resources to take-on anyone they deem in violation of the law. Even if they lose it doesn't mean much to them; they are simply interested in profits and are willing to pursue anyone that may be cutting into them. I think it's fairly obvious this is not a war on copyright infringement but on p2p. The problem with this is an unfair fight; their is only one group who has any real ability to speak. The companies have everything at their disposal from lobbies to friendly media; the p2p world is a collection of individuals relatively silent on the level of communication the companies are capable of (they have great potential but that is all). If not watched, the corporations will eliminate or radically restrict a valuable technology not in public interest but their own. Dictating the development of technology and resources based on that alone is utter madness. Any thoughts on what's to be done about it?

Thursday, October 18, 2007

Free Culture I

In Free Culture Lawrence Lessig addresses blogs (Chapter 2: "Mere Copyists"). He equates the blog with a purer form of Democracy because it is truly ruled by the people. What seems to interest Lessig in blogging is the potential to return to "deliberation." He appears to relish their unregulated power to voice any kind of view (as compared to the mainstream media). What I found interesting was the wistful tone of his description; when he talked about the Trent Lott affair and the tireless efforts of bloggers he sounded firmly in the blogging camp. However the blog is clearly not a news source for any responsible individual, something which he does not take time to address. The blog is unregulated and more importantly unverified--we have no knowledge of the credentials of the writer. While this blog could be quickly transformed into a bugle for satanic Nazi anarchism, whose to say I'm actually the person voicing those (misguided) views? Furthermore there is no fact checking or code of journalist responsibility which is so important in keeping the news from devolving into strictly matters of opinion and slant (granted it seems to be happening in some places--cough, Fox News v. MSNBC--but I believe blogs are nearly entirely this sort of opinion column writing). Lessig says the primary news providers are driven by the need to keep the publics fickle attention. This is, of course, absolutely true. However he then goes on to applaud blogs for their ability to "obsess," etc. Does it sound like a bad thing that a blog story should begin dictating the coverage of traditional news providers? The example of Lott's "exposed" prejudice would seem to clearly contest. However consider another example: the 2004 case of John Kerry and the Swift Boat Veterans. The story appeared early on the news, and then was quickly forgotten as almost every serious journalist understood it to be tripe. However our nation's valuable bloggers (and I cringe as I am now one of them) managed to carry on the search. In what unfolded, they managed to cause such an unwarranted stir they forced the issue back upon the media. This of course became a point of distraction from real and valuable campaign questions, and may have contributed to the re-election of George W. Bush.
Now I don't mean to say blogs should be forbidden from looking at politics and matters of importance greater than whether the blogger likes Frosted Flakes or Rice Krispies. All I'm trying to say is the incredibly vast majority of bloggers are "amateurs." I would like Lessig to prove that the number of trained, competent individuals with access to the means of explaining world events is not a negligible percentage of the blogging whole. How many conspiracy theorists pop up every single day? How many angry partisans simply say a known fact is wrong, allowing some other individual to be comforted in his own view and add weight to his narrow-minded conviction? I think the blog has awesome potential for sharing, thinking out loud, and reasoning through our own beliefs. It is when we trust blogs frequented only by like-minded individuals for our information that we get into trouble. The last thing the country needs is to believe it's us or them. What we need is truth that will challenge and shape where we stand by sole virtue of being truth.

PS
A quick note on Chapter 3. As I was reading the encounter between Jesse Jordan and the RIAA I couldn't help but feel a call to arms similar to the revolutionary. What impressed me was the completeness of the story: an innocent youth looking to do service for the people is grossly and unjustly assailed by the godless institution. The man is defeated by the simple thought of the beast--an illustration of oppression and corruption so clear I struggle to understand how even the very lawyers could miss it (unless they really are soulless). The RIAA juggernaut stole everything the man had, but in the end they only created an enemy. An activist was born from the crimes of the system. My hope is only that it doesn't take a direct encounter with injustice for us to wake up from our apathy and stand behind something other than ourselves. Like every hopeful idealist before me, I don't think the corporations are lobbies are bigger than the people. If we built them, so we should be able to unmake them.

Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Plagiarism Experience Reflection

For me the plagiarism experience came in three distinct emotional stages: first excitement and enthusiasm, then a certain bitterness, and finally a strange acceptance and empathy for the plagiarist.

When we began discussing the project I was really eager to do it. I thought it would be fun and I had quite a few ideas floating around. My goal was to “rip-off” an incredible number of sources and blend them into one seamless paper. I wanted to borrow from everywhere--Calvin and Hobbes, books I’d read years ago with passages still standing out brilliantly in memory, the dilapidated ancient texts of Helen C. White, you name it. I wanted to make my plagiarism epic, on the scale of Ben-hur or the D-Day invasion.

Thus I had several things in consideration format-wise. My original thought was to write a short story. I really enjoy writing creative work and I thought this would be a golden opportunity to try out a scenario with pieces drawn from the work of favorite authors. However as I thought about it I realized there was almost nothing I would want to use word-for-word. I wanted to change things drastically from their original forms, and it became more like I was alluding or making a veiled reference than actually plagiarizing. It certainly wasn’t 25% plagiarized, so I thought about just dropping in the chunks verbatim. The problem with that was just how obvious it was. I realized that because the class would be searching for pieces plagiarized I had no chance of pulling it off (I think maybe with an instructor grading dozens of papers and not aware something has been plagiarized I could have slipped it past). Anyway I also didn’t feel right about doing it, which gradually led to the resentful stage. As Emily commented in class, plagiarizing creative writing is most offensive. Be it pride or something else, I hated the concept that what I was writing wasn’t mine. I decided to bag the entire effort, largely out of annoyance and frustration.

Of course these are midterm weeks and the assignment wasn’t a central focus for most of my time. Over the weekend I went to Iowa for a conference, and didn’t get back until Sunday night. It was then that I gained disturbing insight into the mind of a plagiarist. I’d like to say I purposely waited until 11:30 Sunday night to write the paper in order to feel as a plagiarist feels, however that would be a lie. In fact I was very busy studying for my other classes, all the while remembering the paper was due at 8:50 the next morning. Now for many of you that doesn’t sound all that bad, but I’m a guy that likes going to bed early. In other words, I think I sufficiently experienced the panic, stress, and desperation of a plagiarist. Luckily I had been thinking about the paper while I should have been doing other things all week, so I had some idea what to write. I still had to actually put it down on paper, though. I think this truly reflected the hastiness of plagiarized papers; I wasn’t particularly satisfied with the way it turned out, but there was no other option and no more time. Of course most plagiarists probably don’t lovingly dote over their stolen creations. When I was done I didn’t feel anything except relief that it was over. I didn’t give thought to anything except going to sleep. I imagine were this real the emotions would quickly kick back in after I had turned it in and realized it was now in the position to ruin my academic reputation. Luckily I don’t have to endure that particular fear. My only worry now is whether I’ll win the prize for best plagiarist among my group.

If I didn’t know better I’d say this whole thing was meant to teach a lesson. On the one hand I experienced how guilty i felt plagiarizing someone else’s work. I realized I like the sense of satisfaction I get from making it on my own steam, even if it isn’t regarded particularly highly by an instructor. I also discovered something very unexpected. While I would have originally called plagiarists a variety of negative things, I now have some insight into the humanity of academia’s “them.” They probably aren’t plotting creeps with some bizarre sense of right and wrong; they’re probably very real people with extenuating circumstances. At least that was my story. If this newfound wisdom has inspired me to ask one thing of an instructor, it would be to ask a few questions before offering a plagiarist up to the wrathful gods of higher-education academic honesty. Chances are that person isn’t as much a monster as we’d all like to believe. If we pause for a moment, we might become uncomfortably understanding of someone we've been taught to despise. Chances are, if we look deep enough, there’s a little plagiarist in all of us.

Monday, October 8, 2007

Ghostwriting Reflection

My ghostwriting experience was for a friend in an English course here at the UW. She writes poetry for the class and so it was my job to create a poem using her voice, style, etc.

I really didn't have too much trouble getting into the mentality of writing in a distinctive voice other than my own. I sort of imagined that I was writing a character, in this case my friend, and had to speak the way she would. I didn't have too hard of a time writing the poem either; I've taken a lot of English and am experienced with the conventions and forms of poetry.

The most difficult part of the process for me was mimicking her particular style. She writes very differently from me; our styles of poetry have almost no similarity. I wanted to rhyme and use meter while her style was totally free verse. Thus I was surprised by just how much she had to say when she looked over my original draft. I didn't really expect her to say much, but she pointed out different things she said would never come from her. One of the biggest things she pointed out was that I had let myself as ghostwriter come into the writing. I had used recurring symbols particular to myself to mimic what she had done, but as she informed me, they were completely alien to her.

I really didn't have a moral crisis as I worked on writing "her" poem, but I think that was because I knew all along she wouldn't be turning it in for credit or actually claiming it as her own. At the same time, ridiculous as this will sound, I didn't like the kind of poem that I had to write so I wasn't really concerned about not being credited for it. Maybe if I were really proud of my work, and then knew everyone would always credit it to someone else, I would be upset. I learned that I’m alright with bending the rules because I knew it was pretend. We’ll see if the same holds true for the plagiarism experience, which should be far more extreme.

I think my experience was fairly typical; my author described what she wanted and then told me to fix what she didn’t like. I think more extensive ghostwriting, on say a book length scale, would be far more challenging. Although it was kind of fun this time around, I would never want to do that in the “real” world.

My relationship with the author is intact; actually she was flattered I asked her to do it. In the world of professional ghostwriting I'd guess you're just a tool to be utilized, so this by comparison was a positive experience.