Thursday, November 29, 2007
Some Thoughts on Cut-Up
As I see it, Cut-ups are a strange concept which somehow manages nonetheless to construct an original product. How this is possible when using only other people's work, I'm not really sure. There almost seems to be some magical moment, between the cutting and the gluing, where the Muses breath life into the Cut-up and it begins to stand and walk on its own. I don't know exactly how Cut-ups have been used in the past but I think they have a lot of potential. I don't necessarily think a traditional book could survive a Cut-up, but I think there are certainly other areas that might be interesting to experiment with. I wonder how far the Cut-up method has been taken; into photography, film, art?
My Cut-up is below. I took all the parts from the November 16th, 2007 edition of the Isthmus. The first version is what I imagine a cut-up would look like if you were to unknowingly encounter it. As you read, ask yourself whether you could believe it had been intentionally written word-for-word like it is now. The second one I have color-coded to each article I borrowed from. I just include it because it may be fun to check your suspicions against.
Cut-Up
Isthmus
Whenever a youth is ascertained to possess talents meriting an education which his parents cannot afford, he should be carried forward at the public expense. I know for a fact there is no evidence to connect what the school teaches with any kind of atrocities.
Kids will enlist, but they’ll probably be black-and brown-skinned kids, or Hmong, and blue-collar kids who aren’t laser-focused. You escape by slaying people in dark alleys and grungy buildings. If the sons and daughters of the elite and professional classes were clad in olive drab and routinely being blown up in IED booby traps, the killing can feel a bit like a one-trick pony; hide in a shadow, sneak, kill, repeat. Gangster life is our cultural paradigm, played out as big business by the powerful, as crime by the powerless. In an era of gated communities, privatized public services, Blackwater mercenaries and revived left wing suspicion of the military: savages…eager to glut their savage thirst with the blood of the vanquished.
Murders, torture and other atrocities carried out by soldiers trained at the School of the
Isthmus II (colors indicate different articles)
Whenever a youth is ascertained to possess talents meriting an education which his parents cannot afford, he should be carried forward at the public expense. I know for a fact there is no evidence to connect what the school teaches with any kind of atrocities.
Kids will enlist, but they’ll probably be black-and brown-skinned kids, or Hmong, and blue-collar kids who aren’t laser-focused. You escape by slaying people in dark alleys and grungy buildings. If the sons and daughters of the elite and professional classes were clad in olive drab and routinely being blown up in IED booby traps, the killing can feel a bit like a one-trick pony; hide in a shadow, sneak, kill, repeat. Gangster life is our cultural paradigm, played out as big business by the powerful, as crime by the powerless. In an era of gated communities, privatized public services, Blackwater mercenaries and revived left wing suspicion of the military: savages…eager to glut their savage thirst with the blood of the vanquished.
Murders, torture and other atrocities carried out by soldiers trained at the School of the
Thursday, November 15, 2007
Assorted Thoughts on "Rhythm Science"
DJ Spooky’s “Rhythm Science” sparked new thoughts and questions through surprising means. The writing is really only a part of the argument; the book’s design and execution adds more to the way in which Spooky speaks to us.
The most immediately obvious feature of the book is the hole right in the center. We discussed this fairly thoroughly in class so I’ll only briefly comment. The hole as the first and most logical conclusion is part of the mixing board on the cover and every text page that follows. It penetrates straight through an otherwise solid object, all the way to the “C” side. In a sense turning the pages becomes an act of selecting a record or CD, a degree of control and empowerment is returned to the reader. I liked the comment of one classmate who said that there is no central or definite meaning, only the nothingness it all swirls around (I think Spooky says several times that he’s trying to play around his points, so that seems right on). My thought on the issue is essentially spoken on page 13: “But I’m more concerned with praxis—how to foster a milieu where dialog about culture becomes a way to move into the pictures we describe with words, text, sounds…” It seems to me the hole is an open doorway inside a potentially intimidating work.
The alternating pages are a subject of study. One spread is white and rough while the next is green and smooth. On the white pages comes the expected text of a book, albeit a text interrupted by the hole. The green pages present an illustration and a few words from the previous page (which I only noticed later are also on the white pages). This art is strange but possesses a sort of flow. The quotes are a continuation of the previous page, once written in the narrative and once in the background, next leaping onto the green. The drawings continue this flow to some degree. I notice in most if not all of the drawings there is an element taken from the previous fold. The exact construction of these pages is less clear to me. I think we all grasp the meaning of the “spooky” ghost, but several of the others are a little less clear. The one I saw repeated a lot was the Playboy bunny icon. I didn’t understand why at all until I came to the B-Side. I’m guessing the bunny is “the prostitute” although I’m not sure I understand the full-impact of this. The prostitute seems to be a major part of the argument, so much so that it holds down its own side and encroaches on the other.
A few stray thoughts floating around: I’m still trying to understand the reasons for the scientific terminology that’s so prevalent throughout the book. I know it’s called “Rhythm SCIENCE” but I’m sure there’s more to it than that. There’s also the musician’s terminology—many groups I’ve never heard of. I wonder how it reads to someone inside DJ culture.
As for the C-Side, I haven’t finished listening to the entire thing yet but as I do I’m trying to determine how it’s a continuation of A and B. I think the music could make for a very effective story telling technique because of its power to take us places and make us feel things, while at the same time remaining fairly subjective. In fact I’ve been trying to read the book more like listening to a CD. When I read the first section I wasn’t in the right mindset. I decided to go back later and get in the mood for it. What I found was that the read was far more enjoyable and hit the right note, if you will, when I had the right attitude to go with it. Other than that, I think it’s pretty obvious that the C-Side has crept into A and B. Portions of the text fly away and become musical with just a little beat behind them.
In summary, DJ Spooky’s “Rhythm Science” makes its case in a very strange and multi-dimensional way unusual to the average reader. In building a multi-faceted creation, I think Spooky transcends the constraints of paper and ink and gives his words a life beyond the cover not frequently found in print.
Thursday, November 8, 2007
Further Thoughts on Sampling
That said, I'm curious how everyone went about their Sampling. I tried using the Creative Commons Search Engine (http://search.creativecommons.org/), however I had trouble getting anything of substance with it. Maybe I was looking for the wrong things, but I didn't find it especially helpful. I know Joe said the Directory is a more effective way to go about a search. In the end I basically gave up and just used a bunch of things I drew by hand.
I'm also curious how everyone planned their arguments. I basically brainstormed some thoughts on authorship (no author is entirely free of influence, the author is not limited to the written word, there is a legal battle frequently pitting large established groups against individuals over the future of what can be used, etc.). From there I chose recognizable images that could convey those thoughts, which proved fairly easy. In my Sampling every piece is intentionally placed (for example, the moon and snow are part of the second Sampling for a reason despite looking like filler). I tried to make the overall appearance part of my argument as well, taking space and positions into account. It might take some thought but I believe there are reasons for everything. How did you all do your Sampling?
Tuesday, November 6, 2007
A Reflection on Sampling
While I'm still uncertain what Sampling sounds like in the context of music, I learned that Sampling can be quite effective in making a statement or an argument. Sampling is typically an appeal to the eye, and is therefore made as aesthetically pleasing as possible (something I struggled with as I worked on my Sampling). Sampling can be done relatively quickly, and can carry considerable weight. As I reflected I thought it similar to the old saying: "a picture is worth a thousand words." When an author makes his appeal in the form of Sampling, he engages his audience (I'm not sure the appropriate term) by asking them to read into the work. He encourages them to search, to interpret, to engage the medium in a way that is different from an essay or article.
As I underwent the transformation into Sampler, I quickly realized free access to many resources trumps free access to limited resources. For a Sampling to be effective (in my humble opinion), the Sampler has to connect with his audience on a certain level. The ability to take well-known images from the popular culture can create a more meaningful argument by sheer virtue of recognition. The Sampler's work is understood at a variety of levels because of the cultural subconscious. While an argument made with permissible material can be very effective, it is certainly more difficult for the Sampler to articulate his argument while tip-toeing around legal repercussions. I believe we as a society have universally recognized symbols, many of which are under the ownership of a select few. A Sampling may find ways around the control of these powers and retain the spirit of the argument, but it may lose the power of its message by restraints placed on instantly recognizable images.
Regarding my work, I felt the argument that ripped and reused without concern for legality created a more effective statement. The possibilities were easily more plentiful and I felt I could make the Sampling richer through certain well-known images. I am unfortunately new to Photoshop and similar software, and with time constraints, I ended up making my Sampling by hand. As I thought about that I realized just how much more digital Sampling can do. In that way I felt increasing respect for Samplers. To me they are just as much an author as the individuals who created the elements incorporated in the Sampling. There is a definite creativity, a very clear innovation and alteration, which makes Sampling unique. I think Sampling is the most accurate picture of creation and authorship we have. As has long been known, there is almost nothing written completely uniquely. No author is an island; he is influenced and draws on the work of humanity's greats. It is his manipulation, his tweaking and shifting, his imagination, his new angle, that truly represents authorship.
Thursday, November 1, 2007
Free Culture Reflection
Lawrence Lessig's book "Free Culture" was a considerable divergence from my normal reading habits. I came into the book with next to no knowledge about copyright or the war on free culture. By the time I left, I'd like to think I know a little bit more.
The idea behind "Free Culture" didn’t hold me at first. I believed, erroneously, that the only thing at stake was the online world of piracy. To be honest, I didn’t particularly care if people were no longer able to steal music, movies, books, etc. online. I would have said, “okay, make it impossible and put it back to the way things were. I don’t care.” Lessig woke me from the happy misconception that only the bad guys were at their end and showed me a world teetering on the illogical and bizarre.
I think Lessig presented a powerful case. His examples are numerous and frequently infuriating. In case after case people are crushed by insensitive corporations for the sole purpose of profit. What makes the danger more severe is the threat to the creative future and potential hindrances to advancing our society, both through our culture and technology. I’m not all that naïve about government, but I was nonetheless shocked to hear how the law had been manipulated by the few.
As was suggested in class, I think this is a powerful read because of the passion Lessig brings to the narrative. He is clearly wounded from the Eldred decision, and this as his chance to make things right is not wasted.
For my part I will be sure to listen more closely when news of the legal status of creativity comes up. As a person maybe that’s all you can really do—be aware, I mean, so that when the cue comes up in conversation you can share the truth as best any of us can know it (unless you’re on a date, in which case I would think your company most likely to be disinterested in the nuances of publishing and ownership). In any case I’m grateful for having had the chance to read the book.
PS
My first reaction was to boycott Disney and the other groups operating like gangsters. The problem is that doesn’t really work, because I couldn’t care less about them right now. However once one has children, I imagine it is the “bad” parent who prohibits them from partaking in the 5-year-olds only real culture. Is there any alternative to this, sort of writing and illustrating one’s own line of bedtime stories?
Thursday, October 25, 2007
Free Culture II
As I was considering this my thoughts reflected something Lessig had written earlier in the same chapter: "...the vast majority of it (type C sharing) is unavailable solely because the publisher or the distributor has decided it no longer makes economic sense to the company to make it available." P2P systems are exactly what do not make sense to the company. They are a potentially world-wide distribution system operated under the direction of an individual. Their existence began as outside the control of the corporate powers, and they offered the potential to do away with or substantially downsize an established system. Any competition, no matter how slight, is crushed according to sound business practice. The corporate giants are obviously looking to do just that to squash or control their competition. Despite many benefits of p2p, the record companies and others cannot allow it to flourish because it does not make sense to them. The way things currently are mean the p2p-users are helpless against the company will. The established powers have the capital and resources to take-on anyone they deem in violation of the law. Even if they lose it doesn't mean much to them; they are simply interested in profits and are willing to pursue anyone that may be cutting into them. I think it's fairly obvious this is not a war on copyright infringement but on p2p. The problem with this is an unfair fight; their is only one group who has any real ability to speak. The companies have everything at their disposal from lobbies to friendly media; the p2p world is a collection of individuals relatively silent on the level of communication the companies are capable of (they have great potential but that is all). If not watched, the corporations will eliminate or radically restrict a valuable technology not in public interest but their own. Dictating the development of technology and resources based on that alone is utter madness. Any thoughts on what's to be done about it?